How Successful are Dismissal Appeals
How Successful are Dismissal Appeals

How Successful are Dismissal Appeals

How successful are dismissal appeals? Losing a job because of poor performance, misconduct, or restructuring can be very upsetting for workers. It often leaves them with a sense of unfairness or a feeling that the decision was unjustified.

The emotional impact of losing one’s job can be significant, further getting stronger feelings of frustration and confusion. In these situations, workers may doubt the reasons for their firing and not know what to do next.

This uncertainty can lead them to consider appealing the decision to seek recourse or vindication.

However, appealing a dismissal decision is not always a straightforward process, and success is not guaranteed. To appeal a decision, you must write a formal appeal to the right person within a certain time. Explain why you disagree and give proof.

A group of people reviews the appeal. This group may include members from the employer and employee’s union, as well as a neutral third party. They examine the facts, review any relevant rules, and determine whether the firing was fair and justified. They will look at the facts, check any rules, and decide if the firing was fair and right.

In this article, we will look at how often dismissal appeals are successful to see the chances of winning.

We examine why someone may appeal a dismissal, the strength of the evidence, and the fairness of the process. This helps us determine the effectiveness of appealing a dismissal. By analysing these factors, we can better understand the likelihood of success in appealing a dismissal.

We’ll explore the effectiveness of appeals and provide advice for employees considering appealing their dismissal.

In this talk, we aim to explain the appeal process and help employees make informed choices after being fired.


Understanding the Appeal Process

Before we talk about how often dismissal appeals succeed, it’s important to know how the appeal process works. You might also like our article “How to Fire an Employee” by Wurkplace.

If an employee is fired, they have the option to appeal the decision to a separate group. This group could be an employment tribunal or an internal appeals panel. The group will review the decision and ultimately make a final ruling. This group will review the decision and make a final ruling.

The appeal process examines why someone was fired and the evidence from both the employer and employee.

Ultimately, the determination made by the appeal body is definitive and must be adhered to by all parties involved.

Success Rate of Dismissal Appeals

Dismissal appealby Markus Spiske (

According to a recent study conducted by the Advisory, Resolution and Arbitration Service (ACAS), it was found that the success rate of dismissal appeals is notably low, with only 17% of appeals resulting in a favourable outcome for the employee.

This statistics indicates that a majority of appeals are ultimately unsuccessful, leading to the initial decision to terminate the employee’s contract being upheld.

Despite these discouraging numbers, it is important to note that appealing a dismissal is not entirely without merit. Appeals process helps employer and employee communicate for mutually agreeable settlement, leading to favourable outcome for both.

Factors Affecting the Success Rate

The success rate of dismissal appeals can be influenced by various factors, including the strength of evidence presented by both parties. Good evidence, like witness statements or paperwork, can help an employee win an appeal.

If the employer has strong evidence, the appeal may not succeed.

The success of an appeal can be affected by the type of dismissal. If an employee is terminated for serious misconduct, the chances of a successful appeal may be reduced.

The employer’s strong evidence makes it difficult for the appeal body to overturn the dismissal decision.

The seriousness of the employee’s offense can impact the appeal outcome, as severe misconduct may result in upholding the dismissal.

The Importance of Proper Procedures

The ACAS study emphasized the importance of following proper procedures in employee dismissals. Adhering to correct procedures significantly reduced the success rate of dismissal appeals.

Transparent and fair dismissal protocols are important to reduce the risk of appeals from unhappy employees.

Organisations must establish and communicate clear dismissal guidelines for fair treatment of employees. Take a look at this post where it provides advice on how to deal with grievances.


Based on the data, dismissal appeal success rate is only 17%.

Even if the numbers are not good, it’s important to remember that challenging a dismissal is not a waste of time.

The appeal process can lead to a mutually beneficial settlement or compromise between employer and employee. It’s a chance for both parties to address and resolve any underlying issues that led to the dismissal.

To minimize the likelihood of an employee winning an appeal, employers must adhere to regulations when terminating their employment.

Have you, dear reader, ever found yourself entangled in the complexities of a dismissal appeal? Please share your thoughts and experiences in the comments section below; your insights are valuable to our community.

Reach out today and benefit from our free Audit.

For assistance or advice, consult with one of our professionals today.

You can use our easy online contact form, or call us at 0330 400 5490.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Let Wurkplace Help You Today. Nothing Is Too Small or Too Big, We Have Experts Waiting to Help!Get Help Now!
Scroll to Top

let's talk!

If you need support, we have expert consultants waiting to help.